| 1820 | Hamilton | Delhi | Higdon |
| 1830 | Hamilton | Green Twp | Higdon |
| 1830 | Hamilton | Greene | Higdon |
| 1840 | Hamilton | | Higdon, Higdon |
| 1840 | Hamilton | Cincinnati | Higdon |
| 1850 | Hamilton | Cincinnati | Burke, Greenweal, Hasting, Higdon, Mason, Morris, Powell, Shepherdson, Stagg |
| 1850 | Hamilton | Green and Delhi | Higdon, Nichelson |
| 1850 | Hamilton | Green Twp | Gentle, Higdon |
| 1860 | Hamilton | Cincinnati | DeForest, Hasting, Higdon, Mason, Williams |
| 1860 | Hamilton | Millcreek | Higdon |
| 1870 | Hamilton | Cincinnati | Hasting, Higdon, Markley, Mason, Powell, Williams |
| 1880 | Hamilton | Cincinnati | Hart, Higdon, Rust, Stiles, Williams |
| 1880 | Hamilton | Wyoming | DeForest, Higdon |
| 1900 | Hamilton | Anderson | Higdon |
| 1900 | Hamilton | Cincinnati | Flaherty, Higdon, Stiles, Watters |
| 1900 | Hamilton | Delhi | Wright |
| 1900 | Hamilton | Norwood | Higdon, Nunemaker, Stryker |
| 1910 | Hamilton | Cincinnati | Bales, Flaherty, Fuhrman, Higdon, Morris, Pitzer, Watters |
| 1910 | Hamilton | Delhi | Wright |
| 1910 | Hamilton | Norwood | Higdon, Stryker |
| 1920 | Hamilton | Cincinnati | Flaherty, Fuhrman, Higdon, Witham |
| 1930 | Hamilton | Cincinnati | Flaherty, Higdon, Witham |
| 1930 | Hamilton | Norwood | Higdon |
| 1940 | Hamilton | Cincinnati | Morris |
| 1950 | Hamilton | Cincinnati | Higdon, Morris, Murdock |
