| 1870 | Livingston | Chillicothe | Higdon, Humphrey, Hush, Lair, Seidel |
| 1880 | Livingston | Chillicothe | Humphrey, Lair, Norris |
| 1900 | Livingston | Chillicothe | Humphrey, Hush, Lair, Seidel, Stewart |
| 1900 | Livingston | Wheeling | Andres, Seidel |
| 1910 | Livingston | Chillicothe | Lair, Seidel, Stewart |
| 1910 | Livingston | Wheeling | Andres, Seidel |
| 1920 | Livingston | Chillicothe | Lair, Stewart |
| 1920 | Livingston | Wheeling | Andres, Seidel |
| 1930 | Livingston | Chillicothe | Lair, Miller, Stewart |
| 1950 | Livingston | | Glore, Schrader, Seidel, Seidel |
| 1950 | Livingston | Chillicothe | Glore, Schrader, Seidel |
