| 1840 | Franklin | | Humphrey |
| 1840 | Lagrange | Clearspring | Sprout |
| 1840 | Marshall | | Sprout |
| 1850 | Bartholomew | Haw Creek | Graf |
| 1850 | Boone | | Stephenson |
| 1850 | Dearborn | Dillsboro | Curry, Orange |
| 1850 | Dearborn | Lawrenceburg | Heustis, Martenstein |
| 1850 | Dearborn | Manchester | Heustis |
| 1850 | Decatur | Clinton | Lyon, Sharp |
| 1850 | Decatur | Fugit | Boling, Burkley, Copeland, Crist, Demaree, Gerard, Griswold, Haynes, Higdon, Hopkins, Humphrey, Husted, Locke, Morgan, Ray, Ryan, Slack |
| 1850 | Decatur | Marion | Lawson, Riley |
| 1850 | Decatur | Salt Creek | Cross, Higdon |
| 1850 | Franklin | Bath | Dubois, Husted |
| 1850 | Franklin | Blooming Grove | Culver, Higdon |
| 1850 | Franklin | Brookville | Crist, Updike |
| 1850 | Franklin | Fairfield | Foster, Higdon |
| 1850 | Franklin | Ray Twp | Griswold |
| 1850 | Lagrange | Clearspring | Carsner, Sprout |
| 1850 | Marion | Franklin | Helm, Morris |
| 1850 | Marshall | | Nelson, Sprout |
| 1850 | Ripley | Washington | Bernhard |
| 1850 | Rush | | Hancock, Jones, Lines, Richardson, Sprout, Stephenson |
| 1850 | Rush | Center | Hancock, Sprout |
| 1850 | Rush | District 97 | Jones, Lines, Richardson |
| 1850 | Shelby | Addison | Castator, Chittenden |
| 1850 | Shelby | Hendricks | Baker, Castator |
| 1850 | Union | Harrison | Nelson |
| 1850 | Wayne | Boston | Demaree, Higdon |
| 1860 | Bartholomew | Wayne | Riley, Smithhart |
| 1860 | Boone | Marion | Jones, Stephenson |
| 1860 | Dearborn | Lawrenceburg | Martenstein |
| 1860 | Dearborn | Manchester | Heustis |
| 1860 | Decatur | Clinton | Higdon, Humphrey, Lyon, Sharp, Slain |
| 1860 | Decatur | Fugit | Burkley, Copeland, Crist, Cross, Curry, Foster, Gerard, Griswold, Higdon, Hopkins, Humphrey, Husted, Morgan, Orange, Ray, Ryan, Slack |
| 1860 | Decatur | Salt Creek | Culver, Higdon, Humphrey, Nichelson |
| 1860 | Franklin | Salt Creek | Boling, Humphrey |
| 1860 | Lagrange | Clearspring | Nelson, Sprout |
| 1860 | Marion | Franklin | Helm, Morris |
| 1860 | Rush | Anderson | Jones, Richardson |
| 1860 | Rush | Noble | Lines |
| 1860 | Tipton | Cicero | Stephenson |
| 1860 | Union | Harrison | Worth |
| 1870 | Bartholomew | Wayne | Riley, Smithhart |
| 1870 | Boone | Marion | Jones, Stephenson |
| 1870 | Carroll | Rock Creek | Boling, Gerard, Harris |
| 1870 | Dearborn | Lawrenceburg | Heustis, Martenstein |
| 1870 | Dearborn | Manchester | Heustis |
| 1870 | Decatur | Clinton | Curry, Higdon, Humphrey |
| 1870 | Decatur | Fugit | Burkley, Coombs, Copeland, Crist, Foster, Griswold, Higdon, Hopkins, Humphrey, Ray |
| 1870 | Decatur | Marion | Dugan, Lawson, Riley |
| 1870 | Decatur | Salt Creek | Culver, Higdon, Ray |
| 1870 | Decatur | Washington | Curry, Higdon, Landsman, Morgan, Orange, Slain |
| 1870 | Franklin | Salt Creek | Boling, Humphrey |
| 1870 | Hamilton | Cicero | Humphrey, Ryan |
| 1870 | Lagrange | Clearspring | Sprout |
| 1870 | Marion | Franklin | Helm, Morris |
| 1870 | Rush | Anderson | Hall, Higdon, Jones, Ray, Stephenson, Trullender |
| 1870 | Rush | Richland | Barnes, Higdon |
| 1870 | Sullivan | Gill | Osburn |
| 1870 | Union | Harmony | Husted |
| 1880 | Boone | Marion | Higdon, Jones, Parr, Slain |
| 1880 | Boone | Union | Jones |
| 1880 | Daviess | Veale | Helm |
| 1880 | De Kalb | Butler | Haley |
| 1880 | Dearborn | Lawrenceburg | Heustis, Martenstein |
| 1880 | Decatur | Clinton | Carter, Hall, Higdon, Lines |
| 1880 | Decatur | Fugit | Beach, Burkley, Coombs, Crist, Dugan, Griswold, Harding, Higdon, Hopkins, Humphrey, Husted, Jarrard, Ray, Riley |
| 1880 | Decatur | Greensburg | Riley, Smithhart |
| 1880 | Decatur | Marion | Lawson, Riley |
| 1880 | Franklin | Posey | Higdon, Landsman |
| 1880 | Franklin | Salt Creek | Boling, Humphrey |
| 1880 | Henry | New Castle | Higdon |
| 1880 | Lagrange | Clearspring | Cunningham, Sprout |
| 1880 | Madison | Van Buren | Higdon, Slain |
| 1880 | Marshall | Plymouth | Moon |
| 1880 | Marshall | Polk | Sprout |
| 1880 | Marshall | Tippecanoe | Noonen, Sprout |
| 1880 | Montgomery | Wayne | Boling |
| 1880 | Ripley | Delaware | Culver, Higdon |
| 1880 | Rush | Anderson | Sharp |
| 1880 | Rush | Orange Twp | Barnes, Higdon |
| 1880 | Rush | Richland | Humphrey, Ryan, Stephenson |
| 1880 | Rush | Rushville | Higdon, Matlock |
| 1880 | St Joseph | South Bend | Higdon |
| 1880 | Vigo | Terre Haute | Osburn |
| 1900 | Boone | Center | Higdon |
| 1900 | Boone | Lebanon | Jarrard, Powell |
| 1900 | Boone | Marion | Jones, Slain |
| 1900 | Dearborn | Lawrenceburg | Heustis, Martenstein |
| 1900 | Decatur | Fugit | Crist, Harding, Humphrey, Jarrard, Kerrick, Thompson |
| 1900 | Decatur | Salt Creek | Culver, Dugan, Higdon |
| 1900 | Decatur | Washington | Humphrey, Ray |
| 1900 | Delaware | Gaston | Higdon, Jones |
| 1900 | Delaware | Washington | Higdon, Slain |
| 1900 | Hamilton | Sheridan | Hall, Higdon |
| 1900 | Henry | New Castle | Higdon, Martindale |
| 1900 | Howard | Clay | Higdon, Matlock |
| 1900 | Jackson | Jackson | Hart, Higdon, Jewett |
| 1900 | Lagrange | Bloomfield | Sprout |
| 1900 | Marion | Indianapolis | Higdon, Riley |
| 1900 | Marshall | Tippecanoe | Noonen, Sprout |
| 1900 | Montgomery | Wayne | Boling |
| 1900 | Ripley | Laughery | Higdon, Ray |
| 1900 | Rush | Richland | Humphrey, Stephenson |
| 1900 | Rush | Rushville | Higdon, Lines |
| 1910 | Blackford | Hartford Ward 1 | Martindale |
| 1910 | Boone | Marion | Jones, Slain |
| 1910 | Clark | Jeffersonville | Higdon |
| 1910 | Dearborn | Lawrenceburg | Martenstein |
| 1910 | Decatur | Clinton | Higdon |
| 1910 | Decatur | Fugit | Coombs, Humphrey, Jarrard, Kelsay |
| 1910 | Decatur | Salt Creek | Culver, Dugan, Gwin, Higdon, Ray, Riley, Shepherd |
| 1910 | Decatur | Washington | Humphrey, Ray |
| 1910 | Delaware | Washington | Higdon, Jones, Shaw, Stephenson |
| 1910 | Hamilton | Sheridan | Hall, Higdon |
| 1910 | Hamilton | White River | Hall |
| 1910 | Howard | Kokomo | Higdon, Matlock |
| 1910 | Madison | Van Buren | Higdon, Slain |
| 1910 | Marion | Indianapolis | Higdon, Riley |
| 1910 | Marshall | Tippecanoe | Noonen, Sprout |
| 1910 | Wabash | Chester | Higdon, Lines |
| 1920 | Boone | Marion | Jones |
| 1920 | Decatur | Adams | Buell, Higdon, Humphrey |
| 1920 | Decatur | Fugit | Coombs, Humphrey, Kelsay |
| 1920 | Decatur | Greensburg | Culver, Higdon |
| 1920 | Decatur | Salt Creek | Dugan, Gwin, Higdon, Martin |
| 1920 | Decatur | Washington | Ray |
| 1920 | Delaware | Muncie | Higdon, Stephenson |
| 1920 | Delaware | Washington | Jones, Shaw, Slain |
| 1920 | Hamilton | Sheridan | Hall, Higdon |
| 1920 | Henry | Prairie | Martindale |
| 1920 | Howard | Kokomo | Higdon, Matlock |
| 1920 | Marion | Indianapolis | Higdon, Shepherd |
| 1920 | Marshall | Tippecanoe | Noonen, Sprout |
| 1920 | Wabash | Chester | Higdon, Lines |
| 1930 | Decatur | Fugit | Humphrey, Kelsay |
| 1930 | Decatur | Greensburg | Higdon, Ray, Riley |
| 1930 | Decatur | Salt Creek | Higdon, Martin |
| 1930 | Delaware | Gaston | Jones |
| 1930 | Delaware | Muncie | Higdon, Jones, Shaw, Stephenson |
| 1930 | Henry | Prairie | Martindale |
| 1930 | Howard | Kokomo | Higdon, Matlock |
| 1930 | Marion | Indianapolis | Hall, Higdon, Shepherd |
| 1930 | Marshall | Tippecanoe | Sprout |
| 1930 | Shelby | Addison | Buell, Higdon |
| 1930 | Tippecanoe | Sheffield | Jarrard |
| 1930 | Whitley | Columbia | Higdon |
| 1940 | Dearborn | Lawrenceburg | Martenstein |
| 1940 | Delaware | Muncie | Higdon, Stephenson |
| 1940 | Marion | Indianapolis | Higdon, Shepherd |
| 1940 | Vanderburgh | Pigeon | Higdon |
| 1950 | Decatur | Adams | Humphrey |
| 1950 | Decatur | Newpoint | Bultman |
| 1950 | Decatur | Salt Creek | Higdon, Kriby |
